Perillo's Pizzeria

Discover Perillo's Pizzeria in North Salem, IN for delicious calzones, stromboli, garlic knots, and more. Enjoy outdoor patio dining in a cozy small-town gem. Call +1 765-676-4171!

Welcome to Perillo's Pizzeria

Taste the Difference.

Perillo's Pizzeria
Perillo's Pizzeria
Perillo's Pizzeria
Perillo's Pizzeria

Nestled in the heart of North Salem, Perillo's Pizzeria serves as a beloved culinary gem for locals and visitors alike. This pizza restaurant, located at 5 S Broadway St, prides itself on offering a comforting dining experience that reflects the charm of small-town life. Perillo's is the perfect spot to indulge in satisfying meals crafted from fresh, quality ingredients. The menu features a wide variety of options, from classic New York-style pizzas to cheesy calzones and hearty pasta dishes. Garlic rolls and scrumptious desserts, such as rich cheesecake, add a sweet finish to the experience.

The cozy ambiance, especially on busy Friday nights, makes it a go-to location for a relaxing dinner out, where families and friends gather to share good food and great conversation. Whether it’s lunch or dinner, Perillo’s welcomes customers with warm hospitality and delicious flavors.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

5 S Broadway St, North Salem, IN 46165, United States

Phone

+1 765-676-4171

Social Media

About

The Culinary Story

Perillo's Pizzeria
Perillo's Pizzeria
Perillo's Pizzeria
Perillo's Pizzeria

Perillo's Pizzeria originated from a simple passion for pizza and community-centric dining. Over the years, it has transformed into a North Salem staple. The restaurant is dedicated to providing high-quality food using fresh ingredients sourced from trusted suppliers. Visitors rave about their classic New York-style pizzas, which come with a variety of toppings. Local flavors and favorites like the Margherita and the Meat Lovers reflect the strong culinary culture in the region.

Beyond pizza, the menu boasts an impressive array of calzones, including the Ham and Cheese or the veggie-packed options that ensure every bite bursts with flavor. Other dishes, such as creamy pasta and delightful salads, cater to varied palates, making it a family-friendly venue. Desserts like the famous Limoncello Cake provide a sweet treat, rounding off meals perfectly. One of the highlights of Perillo's is its incredibly busy Friday night, reaching full capacity by 5 PM, which speaks to its popularity.

Though Fridays are buzzing, many locals know that early weekdays offer a quieter dining experience. Take note of their peak hours; by visiting during less busy times, diners can enjoy a more leisurely meal. Furthermore, local events and community gatherings often take place here, enriching the dining experience and fostering connections among patrons. Perillo's Pizzeria embodies the spirit of North Salem, where everyone feels at home while enjoying excellent comfort food.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • Sunday11 AM-6 PM
  • Monday11 AM-2 PM 4-8 PM
  • TuesdayClosed
  • Wednesday11 AM-2 PM 4-8 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-2 PM 4-8 PM
  • Friday11 AM-9 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-9 PM

Perillo's Pizzeria stands out for several key features that enhance the dining experience. The extensive menu includes 42 delectable platters, ensuring there’s something for everyone, from appetizers to desserts. Diners particularly enjoy the calzones and garlic knots, which are crowd favorites. The ambiance of Perillo's adds to its allure; the rustic decor gives a homely feel, inviting guests to unwind. The patio is a delightful spot during warmer months, allowing guests to enjoy their meals in fresh air. Attention to detail is evident in every dish, where even the simplest ingredients shine.

Cash payments ensure a seamless transaction experience, popular among those looking to enjoy a satisfying meal without the fuss of cards. With peak hours bustling and a dedicated local following, visitors can expect lively engagement and prompt service during their time here.

Perillo's Pizzeria

The exterior of Perillo's Pizzeria exudes welcoming charm, making it hard to miss on Broadway Street. Its warm signage and rustic appearance invite passersby to step inside and experience what lies beyond the door. The restaurant features a cozy patio area, ideal for outdoor dining during the summer months. This open-air space allows guests to enjoy their favorite dishes while soaking up the sunshine. The friendly vibe radiates from both staff and patrons, making it a great place to unwind. Lively conversations mix with the aroma of freshly baked pizza, creating an inviting atmosphere that encourages diners to linger longer.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

Having tried to get in Perillo's on two occasions over the weekends, we went on a Monday at noon and had no problem. The restaurant has the atmosphere of having been around for decades. The seating inside is somewhat limited and makes for a great experience. There are patio tables, with nice fall weather it would make for a great dinner. The food as the eight hundred reviews attest is very good. The wife had a calzone big enough for two meals, I had lasagna with meat sauce , again very large. For dessert we had lemon cake, very good and a generous serving. As to the price, for a good lunch with very good service I felt it was worth it.

D
Dale W.

Hey there. Been coming here for years. Our daughter worked here years ago, the place is cute, offers indoor and outdoor seating, authentic foods , great service and we enjoy the atmosphere also. We drive about 30 minutes to get here and it's worth the trip everytime for us. Cash only, don't forget, or there's an atm down the street at the local bank.

M
Mike P.

Best pizza you can get in rural Indiana!

J
Justin M.

Perillo's Italian is one of our family's absolute favorites! The food is always incredible, and it's become a regular request from our kids too. We love sitting out on their patio! It's such a charming atmosphere and there are so many delicious options on the menu. The mussels are one of our favorites and never disappoint! Highly recommend for a family night out or a cozy dinner with friends.

B
Brittani C.

My wife and I have made a drivable bucket list of the best places to eat in Indiana. This restaurant is on the list as part of the 2024 best restaurants in Indiana book. Amazing restaurant and a simple drove NW of Indy. Come and enjoy as you will not be disappointed. We will be back for their pizza with family and friends

E
Eric H.

Ate here twice in 4 months, we live in Orange Beach Al. Family in Greencastle, had Ziti, Spaghetti & meatballs, pizza and a calzone. High quality food and service. We will be back on our next visit, already looking forward to it!

B
Brian B.